Showing posts with label Moon. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Moon. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 25, 2019

Would-Be Asteroid Miners Should Consider What’s in Orbit Around the Earth First



Courtesy NASA


Five thousand satellites pass over your head every day. Only about two thousand are working. The rest are “junk” … inoperative … kaput. They represent approximately $20 billion worth of material floating around in space. The average weight of the currently active 2,064 satellites is 3,212 pounds. If defunct satellites follow that average it means there is 9,936,000 pounds of inoperable satellite in orbit worth $2,075 per pound. Since getting something into orbit costs about $10,000 per pound  the actual value of that unused material in space is worth 120 billion dollars. That is more than is expected to be made from mining many asteroids. This is material that it is known exactly what it is, where it is, it’s already manufactured into useful components specifically for use in space, and it's already in space. Plus, it is much more accessible than even the closest near Earth asteroid. One of the asteroids we have actually been to is Ryugu. It’s estimated mineral value is just 83 billion dollars, and that is before costs to extract it are factored in.

The satellite situation has not gone unnoticed by some. Tom Markusic, founder of Firefly Space Systems, wants to tow these objects to an orbit around Mars where the salvaged components can help out with missions to Mars and the outer planets. Keith Volkert, CEO of Satellite Consulting, Inc., wants to use space tugs to tow these objects to an orbit around the Moon where they can be salvaged at leisure from a small space station orbiting there. The parts would then be catalogued and warehoused for future projects on the Moon or heading outward to Mars or beyond. NASA’s proposed Lunar Orbital Platform Gateway might fill the bill for this purpose, providing an attachment for a combination disassembly dock, warehouse, and habitat. 

Besides making money, the removal of dead satellites from Earth orbit is a very good thing. There are too many of them, and the problem is getting worse. See this great time lapse video to see how big the problem is and how fast it is getting worse. There is the very real possibility of the Kessler Syndrome occurring. A cinematic portrayal of this event was well done in the movie Gravity. This is where a collision between objects in Earth orbit creates more objects in a cascading effect that eventually ruins the possibility of getting anything into orbit without being struck. Mankind could be stuck on Earth for a while. 


Use those plastic grocery bags again. Save money. Save the world. Here’s how.


New technology in thrusters may enable these salvage plans to take shape. Accion Systems has developed an ion thruster on a chip. It does away with a lot of complicated plumbing, bringing the concept down to a chip that accelerates ions and a reservoir of fluid for ion creation. The thruster chip is called TILE — Tiled Ionic Liquid Electrospray. The size of a deck of cards, a TILE has been operated continuously for 42 days straight. The goal is 417 days. That is a lot of time thrusting and one of the things making this technology so promising. 

As far as satellite removal goes, think of a selfie stick with some TILEs and electronics on one end and an attachment mechanism on the other. A swivel to allow directional changes gives us the first space tug chugging its way to the Moon and back, gradually whittling away at all those space debris objects representing orbital Armageddon. 

Phase Four is another company making tiny, efficient thrusters applicable for this situation. Large, high voltage electronics typically produce and accelerate ions in Hall thrusters to move things around in space. Phase Four has reduced these components down to a size you might expect in a cellphone. These components generate radio waves accelerating plasma produced from xenon gas. These efficient little engines could be used to nudge old satellites outward to the Moon, maybe Mars. 

Going beyond the simple salvage, many of these satellites have simply run out of fuel. If they were to be refueled, they would be perfectly good satellites again. A salvage operation could also become a service operation, boosting the value of this material many times over its salvage value. But there is a legal hurdle that must be jumped before salvaging or servicing occurs. By Article VIII of the Outer Space Treaty countries are recognized to have jurisdiction and control over their space objects. Can this be valid after the origin country deliberately abandons the satellite in space? It can’t be a forever situation. 

Once some company goes after an abandoned satellite and the country of origin protests, the U.N. must decide how to handle it. The U.N. should tell that nation that if they still want responsibility for their satellite, they will have to pay for it to stay in orbit. A yearly orbital fee based on the weight of the satellite should be levied by the U.N. on the country in question. I believe a nascent satellite salvage company should press the issue to get things done. The world’s governments and the U.N. are unlikely to spontaneously get around to solving this problem. 

I think we will be hearing more about companies with schemes to remove dead satellites and simultaneously mine them for their valuable components. It is certainly a better plan than destroying  these valuable objects and may even eclipse news and plans for asteroid mining for the near future. 


Other articles you may enjoy:





Outfitting a Mined Asteroid Into a Luxury Solar System Shuttle

The Environmental Advantage of a Space Elevator



Carbon Capture and Sequestration (CCS): The Existential Technology We Are Ignoring






There May Be a Quadrillion Dollars Lying About on the Moon

Mining That First Asteroid - Manned Mission or AI?

A Convergence of Technologies Will Create a New Age of Space Exploration



The Space Habitat Revisited and Revised




























Saturday, March 9, 2019

There May Be a Quadrillion Dollars Lying About on the Moon



Photo by Rachel Moore on Unsplash


The solar wind sweeps out from the Sun in every direction. The Earth is protected from this sleet of particles and energy by the magnetic field that surrounds the planet. The Moon enjoys no such protection. For the last three billion years it has been bombarded by the particle laden breeze, hence the presence of Helium-3 on the Moon. 

Helium-3 or He3, it turns out, can make nuclear fusion a much more efficient process. How much He3 is there? There is an estimated one million metric tons trapped in lunar soil worth about 3 billion dollars per ton.  What!? This is based on the energy it would produce at current prices. That turns out to be three quadrillion dollars, but if fusion were commercially implemented prices would drop, right? So, I reduced the value for the title of the article. Keep in mind, however, the He3 allows fusion to take place without spitting out a bunch of neutrons that create high levels of radiation. This means smaller, even mobile fusion reactors can be built. I may be off a bit to discount it the value by 2/3. Still, wars have been fought over less. 

Now, lo and behold, not only the U.S. but ChinaRussiaIndia, and Europe are planning Moon missions. North Korea and South Korea are thinking about it. Israel’s Moon mission has already begun, launching February 21 of this year. 




This is one of the greatest opportunities of our lifetimes. Nuclear fusion will be accomplished and it won’t be thirty years from now. It will be half that. Those willing to act on this will make Apple’s and Google’s fortunes pale in comparison. The great part is you don’t have to know anything about nuclear fusion to participate in this. NASA is begging for technology to be provided by private industry. So far it is the typical stuff - parts of the Lunar Orbital Platform/Gateway, Moon landers and rovers, logistical vehicles. 

As the mapping of resources on the Moon proceeds it will become more and more obvious how much is there. Not only is there He3. There is water, an invaluable space commodity. It can be used for drinking, cleaning, growing things, rocket fuel, and radiation shielding. Currently it is currently worth about $7,200 per gallon in space. There is one more thing that no one is talking about but it is still there - the 3 trillion kilotons of asteroid material that has collected there over the last 3 billion years. Yes, all of that 3 trillion kilotons of asteroid material, the He3, and the water. Now do you see why everyone wants to go to the Moon, and why the timeline for commercial fusion is not that critical?

There is a problem. All of that wealth, except maybe the water, is distributed evenly on the Moon’s 39 million square kilometers. There is no way it will be mapped completely from orbit. It will require remotely operated and semi-autonomous drones crawling around on the Moon looking for this stuff. These drones should have all the necessary detectors needed plus armor and weapons if the salient countries don’t come up with a treaty on how this wealth is to be divided. Once located, will it just be scooped up and transported to a central processing center or will a processing unit come to the site? Either way, the final product has to be taken to a lunar location or hauled into space and used there or transported back to Earth. Water will never be transported back to Earth, and a surprising amount of the recovered metal may stay on the Moon or in space to build stuff. Most of the He3 will be shipped to Earth, but some will stay on the Moon to run fusion reactors or loaded into interplanetary or even intergalactic probes carrying small fusion reactors. 




Now, re-read the above paragraph and extrapolate the number of devices and logistic vehicles and processing plants and gizmos that are going to be required to do this: Prospecting drones, lunar backhoes, regolith haulers, low gravity material processors that operate in a vacuum, ore furnaces, robotic handlers, surface to orbit shuttles, pre-fab camps for humans, software to control it all. The individuals and companies that start to plan on how to do this and begin working out the details of how all this equipment will be designed will have a jump on billions of dollars worth of revenue. They will also have a jump on the next phase of this process - the 150 million asteroids in the inner Solar System. 


Other articles you may enjoy:

Mining That First Asteroid - Manned Mission or AI?

A Convergence of Technologies Will Create a New Age of Space Exploration


The Space Habitat Revisited and Revised

























Saturday, February 16, 2019

Why Asteroid Mining May First Take Place on the Moon


Lunar outpost - courtesy Wikipedia


The Moon has been bombarded since the beginning of our Solar System with asteroids, meteors, and comet dust. The Moon has almost no erosion. The Moon has not had plate tectonics for billions of years. It has been without vulcanism for around three billion years. Why isn’t someone searching for that material on the Moon? , Helium 3 from the solar wind and water also fall onto the Moon’s surface from space.They are the bonus prize. Some would say they, especially the He3, are the main event and why the Chinese now have a craft on the far side of the Moon. Altogether, the Moon gets hit by about 2800 kg of meteor material per day.

Chinese rover on far side of Moon.


The Moon is 4.5 billion years old. If we assume it has been collecting material at this rate on average for just the last 3 billion  years (from the last period of volcanism) that’s 3 trillion kilotons of meteoritic and asteroid material that is distributed about the Moon’s surface. Unlike Earth, it is still there, undisturbed by weather and oxidation. That is the equivalent of 430 asteroids the size of asteroid 1996 FG3 which is 1.2 kilometers in diameter.

It did not all come down in chunks the size of 1996 FG3, however. It came down in millions of pieces of millions of different sizes from millions of different sources. It is spread over 38 million square kilometers of lunar landscape just waiting for the cleverness of humans to find a way to economically find and collect it.





Let me just state this here for the record. The first asteroid mining will take place on the Moon. Some smart company, using NASA’s Lunar Orbital Platform-Gateway as intended will launch satellites around the Moon to detect various metals or minute fluctuations in gravitational fields to locate deposits of metal on the Moon. Surface-based drones will collect and return this material to a base camp where it will be consolidated and launched back into space and, eventually, back to Earth. If Opportunity can last 15 years, someone can come up with rugged, long-lasting prospector mule drones for the Moon.

Lunar Orbital Platform-Gateway near the Moon - courtesy NASA



Unfortunately, NASA’s Moon rover, Resource Prospector, was cancelled last year by the current administration. NASA intends for  private enterprise to step in and take over the development of hardware. Moon Express is one company offering up designs for vehicles to do the job.

Just yesterday, Valentines Day, NASA announced they wanted the hardware to put astronauts back on the Moon by 2028, and they want commercial enterprise to do it. “This time, when we go to the moon, we’re actually going to stay,” says NASA Administrator Jim Bridenstine. An article from GeekWire about this subject gave the impression NASA was anxious to get this done.



This would seem a reasonable attitude by NASA, given China’s recent return to the Moon and the almost certainty the Chinese are after the biggest energy trove of all time in the form of He3 on the lunar surface. Maybe the U.S. figures two can play that game. In reality, it’s several countries wanting to get to the Moon now. Russia, India, Europe, and Israel all want a piece of the action.

3D printed wall using Moon regolith type material


NASA named nine companies that will be participants in the program known as Commercial Lunar Payload Services, or CLPS. These companies are Astrobotic Technology, Deep Space Systems, Draper, Firefly Aerospace, Intuitive Machines, Lockheed Martin Space, Masten Space Systems, Moon Express, and Orbit Beyond. They will compete for $2.6 billion dollars in contracts over the next ten years. NASA Administrator Jim Bridenstine said the program would concentrate on scientific payloads, “We believe there is a lot of amazing science that we can do on the surface of the Moon.”

3D printer slated for use in space.


With all of this activity ramping up, the first deposit of valuable metal to be found on the Moon may likely be by accident as rovers ply the surface looking for H3 and water. Once discovered, there will be a scramble by corporations and government entities to duplicate this success over and over. Base camps will spring up to support this effort. Base camps will become spaceports, and the Moon will soon become the major jump-off for exploring our Solar System to the limits of human ingenuity and fortitude. And the patter of little feet on regolith derived concrete floors in a vacuum sealed lunar dwelling will herald the true dawn of humanity as a spacefaring civilization.


Other articles you may enjoy:

Mining That First Asteroid - Manned Mission or AI?

A Convergence of Technologies Will Create a New Age of Space Exploration


The Space Habitat Revisited and Revised


























Thursday, November 15, 2018

Are Seeds of Conflict Sprouting On the Moon?



Mineraleater - deviant art



People who really think about mankind as eventually becoming a space-born civilization have realized the importance of the Moon for a long time. The Moon stabilizes the tilt and wobble of the Earth. The high tides it produces could have jump-started and accelerated the beginning of life and evolution. It’s probably absorbed its share of big rocks that would have otherwise hit the Earth. More importantly, for space travel, it represents an anchor and jumping off place for further exploration of our Solar System. We can put things in orbit around the Moon that we might be uncomfortable putting into a near Earth orbit - things like big chunks of asteroid or even a whole one. It can safely orbit the Moon while we mine the goodies from its innards, leaving a potential space habitat shell after it is mined out. It can provide gravity for industrial processes that simply can't be done in micro-gravity or or complete weightlessness. 



Yet, after the Moon shots of the late 60s and through the 70s, the Moon seemed sort of ho-hum. America has been there, done that. It turns out we should have been much more interested in going back with the idea of establishing at least a semi-permanent basecamp. Luckily, there’s been enough interest in the Moon since then to discover that there is water and helium-3 on the surface of the Moon, perhaps a lot of both.

Moon habitat galley mockup - courtesy Wikimedia


The water is very important to mankind’s quest to explore the rest of the Solar System. It represents rocket fuel (hydrogen & oxygen), radiation shielding for spacecraft, and you can drink it and grow stuff with it. Don’t forget ice sculptures. The main thing is that it is in a much shallower gravity well than Earth water, which makes it easier and cheaper to get into space where it will be used. 

Moon Colony - courtesy Wikipedia


The helium-3, it turns out, can make nuclear fusion a much more efficient process. How much is there? There is an estimated one million metric tons trapped in lunar soil worth about 3 billion dollars per ton. What!? Wars have been fought over less. 

This is not to mention; okay, yes, I’m mentioning it; the millions of years the Moon’s surface has been bombarded by the very asteroids our nascent asteroid mining industry purports to want to go mine. That material has been laying there on the Moon’s surface undiminished all this time. Maybe this idea just occurred to a number of people all over the world at the same time. Why? Not sure, but ....

Now, lo and behold, not only the U.S. but China, Russia, India, Europe, and Israel are planning Moon missions. North and South Korea are thinking about it. Go figure. Is it really in the interest of science, or is it a game of finders keepers? The reality of nuclear fusion is always 30 years in the future according to the fusion energy mavens, but reality is catching up with everybody on everything. Artificial Intelligence is advancing quicker than nuclear fusion, and when it - a general AI, not some savant - happens, there will be advances in a lot of ideas that are on the cusp. Those that weren’t smart enough to realize the worth of the Moon for it’s natural gravity harbor properties are smart enough to realize the tremendous wealth, energy, and power now represented by the Moon. 

Let us hope all that wealth and power does not attract those who simply want wealth and power for its own sake. Let us hope it attracts those with the vision to use that wealth and power for the betterment of all mankind rather than a privileged few. Let us also hope all parties involved can figure out a peaceful means of dividing up resources on the Moon. Fingers crossed.


Other articles you may enjoy:



























Tuesday, November 13, 2018

Just What Are NASA’s Plans Under Trump?


Jovian clouds. Courtesy NASA



At the behest of President Donald Trump’s Space Policy Directive 1NASA is planning a more hands-on advance into space called the National Space Exploration Campaign. That will include human hands returning to the Moon. Hopefully, by the time he finds out there is no golf course involved, NASA will be too far along to cancel the campaign. 


Astronauts on the Moon. 


“The directive I am signing today will refocus America’s space program on human exploration and discovery,” said President Trump. “It marks a first step in returning American astronauts to the Moon for the first time since 1972, for long-term exploration and use. This time, we will not only plant our flag and leave our footprints -- we will establish a foundation for an eventual mission to Mars, and perhaps someday, to many worlds beyond.” 


Mars base. Courtesy NASA.


A lot of people disagree with the President about going back to the Moon. Some, Elon Musk included, think we should go to Mars first. The Donald’s reasoning, semi-joking about the golf course, probably does not involve harvesting helium-3 or turning the Moon into the first intra-solar system gas station by electrolyzing Moon water into hydrogen and oxygen. It probably has something more to do with national prestige on the world stage. The helium-3, should we ever get fusion to work, and the water thing are much better reasons. Whatever works. Even a blind pig finds an acorn now and then. 

Space Policy Directive 2 streamlines the regulations and licensing for commercial space companies, forming a one-stop shopping place for a single license to cover commercial space exploration and exploitation by any corporation.



Space Policy Directive 3 is the administration’s attempt to make information about space debris more accessible by allowing the Department of Commerce to take over part of the responsibilities of tracking and charting the thousands of pieces of space debris and letting the info get into the hands of commercial entities that need it. An addendum, so to speak, of Directive 3 was President Trump’s call for a “Space Force”. 

These directives have coalesced into a campaign by NASA with goals corresponding to these directives. 


Jupiter - courtesy NASA.


The National Space Exploration Campaign has five strategic goals:
  1. Transition U.S. human spaceflight activities in low-Earth orbit  to commercial operations that support NASA and the needs of an emerging private sector market.
  2. Lead the emplacement of capabilities that support lunar surface operations and facilitate missions beyond cislunar space.
  3. Foster scientific discovery and characterization of lunar resources through a series of robotic missions.
  4. Return U.S. astronauts to the surface of the Moon for a sustained campaign of exploration and use.
  5. Demonstrate the capabilities required for human missions to Mars and other destinations.

These directives and campaigns seem, on the surface, to be a positive for the space program. What needs to be watched is whether good science projects are being scrapped to make budget room for spectacular stunts, like men on the Moon … again. If we do wind up with people on the Moon, let’s hope it is for much longer periods so worthwhile scientific studies can be made that will help out in the journey to Mars. 

One of the tactical goals for NASA is to have a Lunar Orbital Platform-Gateway (LOP-G) permanently stationed in orbit around the Moon. Like a mini-ISS, it will house personnel, equipment, and experiments. It will serve as a base camp to the Moon’s surface and a service station to missions beyond the Earth-Moon envelope. This used to be the Deep Space Gateway under Obama, but Trump couldn't stand it that there was a program under Obama that he actually agreed with, so the name was changed. The name is now so awkward there may be another renaming. 


LOP-G Lunar Orbital Platform - Gateway. A space station for the Moon.


Parts for the LOP-G are already being fabricated all over the world. These will be launched into space using NASA’s Space Launch System or, possibly SpaceX’s Big Falcon Rocket and ferried to the Moon aboard something like a Orion, the BFR Spaceship, or a logistics module that NASA has recently signaled it needs designs for from private industry. Once in orbit around the Moon, the pieces will be assembled to form the LOP-G. 

From the LOP-G, small landers will go to the Moon’s surface and explore for minerals, metals, and water. Moon Express is a company developing new lunar landers to facilitate this push to go back to the Moon. If what they find is favorable, it may not be long before astronauts in habitats are camping out on the Moon. It may turn out to be the golden age of manned spaceflight. With the quickening pace of AI development, it will soon make more sense, even to politicians, to leave the heavy lifting of space exploration in the hands of more capable machines. 


Other articles you may enjoy:



Are Seeds of Conflict Sprouting On the Moon?